Glee's Jayma Mays wore a ruffle plaid shirt, BCBG skirt and gold sandals to the Fox 2010 Summer All-Star Party. Recreate her adorable, preppy-chic look on a budget with fashions from Express, Aeropostale, J. Crew and more!
 Ruffle Shirt, sale $24.99, aeropostale.com
 Schooner Belt, sale $12.99, jcrew.com
 Navy Pencil Skirt, $49.90, express.com
 Metallic Trimmed Glass Bracelet, $5.80, forever21.com
 Chinese Laundry 'Drastic' Gold Wedges, sale $48.30, macys.com